The first half of ‘The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power’ season 3 fixes all the wrong problems

By Josh Ball

For fans of J.R.R. Tolkien’s “The Lord of the Rings,” Amazon Prime’s attempt to adapt a show stood as the pinnacle of postmodernism. Aside from the destruction of Middle-Earth’s established lore, the first two seasons served as examples of how not to tell a story. After four years of fan backlash, Amazon Prime fixed many of the problems in the first half of season three, but left some of the biggest unresolved and created confusion in their effort.

One of the biggest complaints early in the show was the bloat of the show. Too many plotlines competed for screentime, ultimately leaving them all with too little and entirely unsatisfying. 

In season three, the mass of characters is much less, allowing for a more coherent story. Earlier seasons were a plethora of disconnected actions and storylines. In season three, every decision affects every other character’s situation. The reduced cast of characters frees screentime, and the writers take advantage. Traveling across the world used to feel like teleportation, but in season three feels like an actual adventure. It is amazing.

Celeborn (Jamie Campbell Bower) and Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) meet for the first time in a touching moment.

The acting is much improved. Onboarding Jamie Campbell Bower as the Elf-lord Celeborn is an amazing decision. He brings gravitas to the role while portraying the restraint it needs. His delivery on every line of dialogue enthralls the listener, and his timing in the comedic moments is impeccable.

Some portrayals of characters are better. It is refreshing to see Sauron (Charlie Vickers) revel in his evil — being evil because he likes it. For once, in a world obsessed with grayness which avoids clear moral distinctions, the villain is truly, purely and only evil.

Unfortunately, that is where the praise must end. Though the story is told much better, there remains the unshakable feeling that the first draft of the script made the screen. The writers continue their effort in emulating the immortal wisdom of Tolkien and his particular style of writing. Their failure results in unbearable dialogue marked by the jarring feeling that no one talks the way these characters do, nor did they ever. Though acted and delivered well, there is no saving the actual words that are being spoken.

Sauron spends the first half of the season hunting a secret he possessed in the previous season. After teaching the elves to forge magic rings in season two, he somehow forgets the craft as he sets about forging the One Ring. Worse, Sauron manages somehow to control the Lesser Rings without his Ruling Ring. These continuity problems and plot holes could have been caught but inexplicably find themselves in the final cut.

Nobody has any sense of a moral code or conscience. Any time someone shows some spine or takes a firm moral stance, he is immediately cut down and shown to be a biased fool. This problem cascades into fundamental flaws in the characters who take the forefront, revealing a deep misunderstanding of the source material. Tolkien’s heroes embody the traditional values of the West: courage, loyalty, strength and more. They give the reader an ideal for which to strive. The writers on “The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power” create cowardly fools who cannot serve as role models.

Durin IV (Owain Arthur) and Disa (Sophia Nomvete) rule the Dwarven kingdom Khazad-dum.

The lack of a clear moral compass in the show causes problems when clearly wrong decisions come to light. Disa (Sophia Nomvete) must own up to mistakes in her past. Instead of owning her actions and begging forgiveness, she minimizes a frankly horrendous decision and acts like there should be no consequences.

The first half of season three of “The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power” shows a reluctant willingness to take audience feedback. The showrunners fixed a lot of problems in making a show. Bright spots in acting are erased by the dialogue and characterization. Instead of role models and ideals, viewers are left with characters whose examples leave something to be desired. Overall, the show is headed in a positive direction, which should give Tolkien fans hope for the future of this adaptation.

“The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power” is streaming on Amazon Prime

Josh Ball is a senior history major and a huge fan of Tolkien. He will be embarking on a marathon of the extended editions of Peter Jackson’s films.

Images courtesy of Amazon Prime Studios

No Replies to "The first half of ‘The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power’ season 3 fixes all the wrong problems"

    Leave a reply

    Your email address will not be published.