‘Being Heumann’ needs a title change to ‘being a protestor’

By Danielle Cherry   

Blindness, deafness, wheelchair-bound, unable to speak, and unable to walk are only a few of the words to describe the characters in this movie. Being reduced to “feeble-minded,” “unable” and “uneducated,” the fight for equality is on the rise with Judy Heumann at the front. 

Based on the true events of the 28-day San Francisco Federal Building occupation in 1977, “Being Heumann” portrays the struggles people with disabilities had to fight through in order to pass the 504 Rehabilitation Act.  

In an effort to persuade congressman Joseph Califano (Mark Ruffalo) to sign the Act, Heumann and an entire crippled community take up residence in the Department of Health, Education and Welfare’s (HEW) building — leading the longest nonviolent sit-in in revolutionary history. Heumann, unable to use her legs because of polio, sees an opportunity for a revolution — that one signature would change the world for her and the entire disabled community. 

As the self-appointed leader of the group, Heumann is harsh and demanding on many levels, truly believing the only way to win is to be unrelenting on every front, even when it puts those around her in jeopardy. 

Supported by a cast with various disabilities, “Being Heumann” pushes a radical agenda forward  from all sides. From the inequality faced by disabled persons to the injustice performed by the government, this movie screams in every frame that justice is a necessity. 

Unfortunately, all the screaming causes the message to get lost in political slander, hatred towards the government and outright radicalism. I want to be clear, people with disabilities deserve every right that non-disabled persons do — but that message gets lost with all the noise “Being Heumann” brings into the plot 

Full of crude jokes and unnecessary humor, this movie is entirely too long for the goal it is trying to accomplish. On top of that, Heumann is entirely rude and self-absorbed which makes her a hard character to like. 

Who really steals away the show is reporter Evan White (Dylan O’Brian). Faithfully covering the disabled’s political revolution, White goes to the congressman to be the voice for those unable to be in the conference room. 

From being unable to understand the disabled community to being their advocate, Evan White (Dylan O’Brian) is truly the hero of this story. 

Covering their story from start to finish, Evan White is a true example of what real and raw reporting looks like — that telling the truth is telling the right messages and sending those to the public. More so than any other aspect of the movie, White’s actions were the most humane treatment that the disabled community received. 

Despite an entirely too long plot with questionable writing choices, Ruth Madley as the ferocious Heumann is a beautiful casting choice. Embodying the blunt and driven nature of Heumann, Madley’s own struggles with her disabilities bring a raw energy to the character. 

For the first time in a long while, Mark Ruffalo gets to play a bad guy and Dylan O’Brian a good one. Both brought nuance to their characters and showed different sides of their acting ability — hopefully demonstrating to the industry that confining them to type-casting is not a full extension of their capabilities. 

Unfortunately the 28-day protest is very felt in the length of this movie, with the majority of dialogue being protests or government slander. After the first 30 minutes with no break in dialogue, the viewer loses interest — making the rest of the two hour runtime a slog to wheel through. 

Another press conference meeting, where nothing much gets said or accomplished

What would have been nice was more discussion on the people who were fighting for this revolution. Rather than focusing on the act that needed a signature, focusing on the individuals who had disabilities would have conveyed a more powerful message than people just yelling with signs.

A chance for the viewer to see Heumans’ struggles or to understand the way the disabled community is treated would have brought a lot more heart into a movie utterly lacking one. Despite so much passion demonstrated in the revolution, there is none from the viewer who passively watches, wondering when it will end. 

Revolution takes voicing an opinion, but not knowing the stories behind that opinion makes the power of the message fall short. The public can look up the 1977 sit-in and discover the same story “Being Heumann” told. What would have made the difference was revealing a different side to the narrative. 

Ironically the whole point of the movie becomes void, as once again it’s only Evan White who tries to tell a different side of the story. And unfortunately for “Being Heumann” — White’s spin of the revolution never makes it to the big screen.

“Being Heumann” is currently streaming on Apple TV+

Danielle Cherry is a junior communication major and is assistant editor and writer for A&E and passionate writer for Sports. She is a Missionary Kid from Germany and has never witnessed quite so much protesting in her whole life. 

Images courtesy of Apple Original Films

No Replies to "‘Being Heumann’ needs a title change to ‘being a protestor’"

    Leave a reply

    Your email address will not be published.